Over the past two weeks, just as Christian doomsayers were being proved false, Freddie Mercury’s 1984 prophecy came true for a whole news cycle: all we heard was Radio Gaga. The entire media sphere was tuned in to the station—”American Idol,” “60 Minutes,” “Saturday Night Live,” “The View”—all visited by the supernova-ing Lady Gaga as she promoted her new Born This Way CD and its message of self-acceptance. Announcing the singer’s top ranking on Forbes’ “Most Powerful” list, “The View”’s Sherri Shepherd boiled the moment down to just one stat: “You have knocked Oprah Winfrey down to number two, girl.”
Sort of. The “power” calculus by which Forbes ranks the $90 million–earning Gaga over the $290 million-earning Oprah isn’t much more scientific than the one Time uses to gauge “influence” (double the Twitter followers, add half all Facebook friends). But this nominal dethronement does speak to what must happen to an artist around her 9 millionth Twitter follower, when it sinks in that all your little monsters are actually listening: you don’t depose Oprah so much as become her.
On Monday, Gaga told “The View”‘s matriarchal Rushmore that with fame, “suddenly there’s lots of pressure and you have to be a role model and I had to look inside myself and I had to say, ‘Well, what do I have to offer?’”
Let us postulate that the last place a 25-year-old pop star should look for something to offer is inside herself. Let us add that the last role she should assume is Gaga’s stated one, to serve as “a vehicle for the voice of my fans.”
From the moment this club-kid version of Carole King launched as pop star, her talent was as obvious as her star-making strategy: grimed-up ADD Bowie/Madonna boilerplate (glam, perv, religious iconography), fine-tuned by industry mandarins, and plugged into the mainframe. The only surprise was how well the machine still worked. “Bad Romance,” “Paparazzi,” and other Gaga songs outshone their chart-topping neighbors without trying, her raw-meat and Kermit couture delighted and grossed out, and the studious provocateur kept things arch and chilly.
What a difference a million followers makes. Born This Way is a solid collection of club thumpers, using Black Eyed Peas’ dance-mix aggregation tactics with infinitely better punchlines. But if her art-school team still skews more Banksy than Mr. Brainwash, Lady Gaga’s more personal platform has taken on a creepily pan-inoffensive monotone, the same one heard in her Tweeted response to the death of Bin Laden: “Watching CNN, what a historical moment in the fight against hatred.” Meanwhile, the same singer whose just-barely pixelated crotch shot in 2010’s “Telephone” video somehow read elusive is now nurturing her little-monster acolytes with music that’s more and more audibly regressive, sharing an inner-child message she summarized on “The View:: “Be yourself and love who you are and be proud because you were born this way.”
Born what way? It’s obvious what self-acceptance should and does sound like for an Italian-American named Stefani Germanotta, born in 1986, the year the smash True Blue album coronated one Madonna Ciccone. But while Lady Gaga always looked aughts and sounded late-eighties, the similarity between her album’s title song and Madonna’s ‘89 “Express Yourself” is only the most noted of Born This Way’s apparent Freudian slips. As Gaga told an interviewer, the Madonna-isms that are both too profound and superficial came to her in a flood of unmediated inspiration that the “magical message song” “Born This Way” came to her by, as she put it, “an immaculate conception.” Whether or not she’s kidding about the songs’ genesis, by the time the ”La Isla Bonita”-ish Italo-español of “Americano” segues to the echoing “Like a Prayer” verse of “Fashion of His Love,” then into the “Oh Father” declaration of “Bloody Marry,” and then to the “Vogue”-clipped spoken chorus of “Black Jesus”…. Well, the message sounds like a faint echo of some early-nineties Act Up slogan. And unlike Madonna’s celebratory mode of addressing that era’s dead-serious gender issues, Lady Gaga’s arch/sincere toggle switch for IM-ing uplift comes off strikingly didactic. (Thank God for lines like “Jesus is the new black.”)
If these times qualify anti-hate and pro-self-love as messages, Gaga is surely helping her marginalized little monsters—all 10 million of them. But when the message leads the medium, pop music always suffers, and “it gets better” is not a killer hook.
A little over a year ago, then-23-year-old Lady Gaga gave this magazine the Warhol party line: “In art, as in music, there’s a lot of truth—and then there’s a lie. The artist is essentially creating his work to make this lie a truth, but he slides it in amongst all the others. The tiny little lie is the moment I live for.”
This is as much message as any superstar should need. Lady Gaga is too smart and talented to star in an after-school special with wardrobe borrowed from “RuPaul’s Drag Race,” which is what the spokesman role does to her persona. As they say, if one kid’s life is saved by Born This Way–era Lady Gaga (morphing as you read this) it’s all worth it. Perhaps some algorithm can weigh this against the one gay, sickly Catholic Pittsburgh coal-miner’s son who, had he access to Gaga’s Twitter, might not have had to become Andy Warhol. Let’s hope Lady Gaga rediscovers her love of tiny little lies.